I support HB 2632 because I believe that if you have to pick up the difference for tax breaks, you have a right to know who those tax incentives are helping and whether the programs incentivized by the tax incentives are serving the students they claim to serve.
Correcting the record on what HB2632 does and does not do
Over the last week many constituents in the district have been inundated with deceptive text messages and email campaigns that preyed on the understandable concerns of families whose students or private and parochial schools are supported by EITC scholarship funds, including messages specifically targeting our local Catholic school communities.
It was important to me that we swiftly correct the record. On Wednesday, I sent letters to Archbishop Nelson Pérez and the Archdiocese of Philadelphia, and to the leaders of Bishop Shanahan High School. Each letter outlines the facts about HB 2632 and addresses the inaccuracies that were shared with families. I asked each organization to please correct the record on misinformation sent to their followers and school communities, and I have invited them to reach out or meet with me if they have further questions about the bill.
Read my letter to Archbishop Pérez here.
Read my letter to Bishop Shanahan here.
I voted in support of HB 2632 because it closes those gaps and provides the oversight the public deserves. The bill now heads to the Senate for consideration.
House Passes Legislation that would rein in Data Center Tax Breaks
On Thursday, by a vote of 197-5, the House passed legislation to repeal and eliminate the Sales and Use Tax Exemption for data centers.
I was an early cosponsor and supporter of this legislation (HB2198), which was introduced and championed by Environmental Committee Chair Rep. Greg Vitali, and I am thrilled to see it receive such overwhelming bipartisan support.
Chair Vitali has been a steadfast leader on environmental issues and an unwavering voice for justice throughout his tenure in the House. He is the very definition of someone who has come to Harrisburg to do this work with integrity and do it for the right reasons. His voice and his unrelenting advocacy will be missed, as he will retire from the House at the end of this session.
I believe Chair Vitali’s proposal to repeal the data center tax credit outright is the right thing to do. These billion-dollar corporations do not need tax breaks, and we should not be working to attract this energy-hungry and water-intensive industry to our communities.
I also have great respect for the work of my colleague Rep. Joe Webster, whose GRID legislation (HB2650) I also voted to support this week. Rep. Webster fought hard to make this legislation as strong as possible, and it would be a meaningful improvement over the data center tax break free-for-all we have today. His bill attaches meaningful conditions around energy costs, environmental protections, and community input where currently we have none, and it shortens the duration of the tax exemption from 25 years to 10 years.
GRID passed the House by a vote of 134-68, the day before our vote on Chair Vitali’s repeal bill. This legislation is not a substitute for repeal, but it’s a meaningful improvement over the free-for-all we have today, and I support any serious effort to rein in this industry’s blank check, even as I keep pushing for full repeal.
I voted against the expansion of the data center sales tax exemption in 2021 because then as now, it prioritized corporate profits over the public interest and failed to include any provisions to protect Pennsylvania communities.
GRID isn’t the finish line. It’s a floor, not a ceiling. I can support the guardrails it proposes while I keep advocating for full repeal. What I cannot support is the current free-for-all giveaway to billionaire corporations. Refusing to support any improvement because it isn’t total victory, leaves the current free-for-all fully intact.
What GRID doesn’t fix: it leaves the underlying tax credit in place for anyone who meets the certification bar. And it doesn’t address the projected cost to the state, which the administration puts at over $500 million a year by FY 2030-31.
Now that both Chair Vitali’s repeal bill and Rep. Webster’s GRID legislation have passed the House, their fate is in the hands of the Senate, specifically Senate Majority Leader Joe Pittman.
Public sentiment and bipartisan support, including near-unanimous support from the House for full repeal of the tax credits, make the desired outcome clear. Now Senator Joe Pittman has a responsibility to act.
For more information, Spotlight PA has a good overview of the conversation around these bills.